Case result · Ontario Court of Justice · Jake Shen, Shen’s Law Professional Corporation · 11D.ca
Two counts of robbery and one count of dangerous driving were withdrawn in the Ontario Court of Justice, and our client received a conditional discharge on a single count of assault — no criminal conviction was registered, and he was not removed from Canada.
Case result
| Charges | Robbery × 2, dangerous operation of a motor vehicle, assault |
|---|---|
| Court | Ontario Court of Justice, Windsor |
| Key issues | Whether our client drove at the complainants; whether anything was taken |
| Evidence | Client’s dashcam, scene photographs, 911 audio, four sets of police disclosure |
| Result | Both robbery counts and the dangerous driving count withdrawn; conditional discharge on assault |
| Record | No conviction registered |
| Immigration | Permanent residence application preserved; removal from Canada avoided |
The situation
Our client was a delivery-depot manager working in Ontario on a work permit — no criminal record, a Canadian-born daughter, and a permanent residence application in preparation. A workplace dispute with two contract couriers escalated into a collision between two vehicles and a physical altercation. Police arrived to find the couriers’ phones and a wallet in his hands, and charged him with two counts of robbery, dangerous operation of a motor vehicle and assault.
The obstacle
Robbery carries a maximum of life imprisonment. For a non-citizen, a conviction is serious criminality under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act — enough to end a permanent residence application and lead to removal from Canada. An officer’s notes recorded that our client had driven his van at the two men, and the dangerous driving count rested on that. He had already lost his job to a release condition keeping him out of the driver’s seat.
What we did
Rebuilt the evening from the client’s own dashcam
Dozens of clips had been recorded and never put in order. We sequenced them into a minute-by-minute timeline of the hours before, during and after the incident. The footage showed the van parked in one spot throughout the altercation, contradicting the allegation that our client drove at anyone. Scene photographs showed tire tracks through the grass from one vehicle only, and it was not his.
Pressed for complete disclosure
Four rounds of further disclosure were obtained over six months: 911 call-taker audio, body-worn and in-car camera footage from nine officers, typed transcriptions of illegible notes, and the booking video.
Tested the grounds for every count
One complainant told police he had left his wallet and phone in his car and that our client picked them up afterwards — putting the taking element of robbery squarely in issue. The police version behind the dangerous driving count matched neither complainant’s statement. The information to obtain a warrant for the client’s phone was challenged for accuracy and absence of grounds, and the adequacy of the right-to-counsel caution was raised where comprehension was in question.
Negotiated without conceding
At the judicial pre-trial and in the agreed statement of facts, the competing accounts of the collision were preserved on the record rather than given away. Sentencing submissions set out an early resolution, no record, a decade of study and work in Canada, family responsibility and remorse.
The result
Both robbery counts and the dangerous driving count were withdrawn. Our client received a conditional discharge on the remaining assault count, so no conviction is registered once probation is completed — and he kept his permanent residence application and his life in Canada.
Common questions
Can a robbery charge be withdrawn in Ontario?
Yes. Robbery is often laid where the facts support something narrower, such as assault or theft. Where the video and disclosure work is done early and the Crown can be shown that an element of the offence is not made out, robbery counts can be reduced or withdrawn before trial.
Does a conditional discharge leave a criminal record?
A conditional discharge is a finding of guilt without a conviction. Once the probation period is completed, no conviction is registered. The record of the discharge is purged from the CPIC database three years after the probation ends.
Can a criminal charge affect a work permit or PR application?
Yes. A conviction for an offence punishable by ten years or more, or one drawing a sentence over six months, is serious criminality and can make a foreign national inadmissible to Canada. Assess the immigration consequences of a plea before entering it, not afterwards.
Disclaimer. This case summary is advertising material provided for general information only. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Names, initials and identifying details have been omitted or altered, and the summary is published in anonymized form with the client’s consent. Past results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any other matter; every case turns on its own facts, evidence and court. If you are charged with an offence, speak with a lawyer about your own situation.
Areas served. Toronto and the Greater Toronto Area from offices in Markham, Toronto and Gilford — including Scarborough, North York, Etobicoke, Mississauga, Brampton, Markham, Richmond Hill, Vaughan, Pickering, Ajax, Newmarket, Barrie and Bradford. Other Ontario courts on request.
Contact. Chen (Jake) Shen, Barrister & Solicitor · Shen’s Law Professional Corporation · Telephone: (647) 390-1131 · Email: jake.shen@11d.ca · Website: www.11D.ca